As to you being an old school gamer and biased against motion controls in SS to this I say, there is nothing wrong with trying out a new system, there Is something wrong when you try out an unintuitive piece of crap system. Wii's motion controls work just fine for some games and are terrible for other games.
I actually like the first two more, I think they did a fine job adding story where there really was none. Friend feels the same as you though. I like all of them though.
Yeah Doom has been one of the most important games in my life . I even named my son after the main character in the books. You should check out Doom 64 EX if you haven't ( google it ).
Hey, just wanted to let you know, the next time I jump on my PS3 I'm gonna send a friend request. So if you don't mind it, keep an eye out for mine, which is SOOSHI_SHEF