@Caps:
No, it does not. The clarification on the wording is one thing, but your logic wasn't confusing me at all. Rather, your approach to me in lieu of the tie vote (of which I could have avoided had I bothered to vote Deku in the first place) is suspect since you're talking likelihoods. The likelihood that all votes on me were town (by virtue of two having been killed on me and one, potentially, being a vig type hit as opposed to both kills being mafia controlled). Further, I see no due diligence on your part in factoring that, the tie vote, into your assessment of me even after your admittance that "it was a hole in my logic" and nothing further. I'll grant that I haven't read beyond your first question so I'll see if you actually give serious contemplation to the entire situation as opposed to just one part (which had to be brought up by me no less wrt to you talking about me).
*
I said it was possible for you to be scum and for another scum to be between myself, Funnygirl, Ex, and Fig. I think it's likely there is one scum on the Deku wagon regardless because I highly doubt that all the mafia are between Naga and those not on a major wagon.
For what it's worth, I missed that assertion.
That's a fair accusation.
And there we have it.
Thinking back to this and knowing at least something about each player on the KoD wagon I'm now more unsure about KoD being town. I think it's possible if KoD is scum that there was no effort to save him because perhaps there were already scum on the Deku wagon to the point where they didn't expect the wagon to build fast enough for lynch to be a possibility? Regardless I think there is likely one scum on the Deku wagon based solely on wagonomics.
With all that you've said, your logic is definitely baffling, and you're certainly avoiding giving fair consideration to the more plausible scenario that no one bothered breaking the tie (wrt to scum) because they didn't care who died. The fact that I lived and now have you, at several points, pointing and saying, "KoD may be scum," is a great indication to how insincere you are to doing the due diligence necessary to assess the context of the tie vote and my continued existence [as likely town as opposed to scum].
The third quote here is your initial wording regarding your thought process. Straight up, you are
UNSURE of me being town, and go on to flesh out why it is possible for me to be scum. The idea you craft is strictly scum couldn't have saved me due to their votes were already on the Deku wagon (and they didn't react to my wagon because they didn't expect such a flash wagon while having already been on Deku's and thus being unwilling to unvote from there).
But it gets better.
Despite what you craft, you then say you believe that at least one scum is on Deku (not both scum, at least one) which leaves up in the air where the other scum is. You've already spoken at length of Naga. If he was scum, then he was trying to bus me were I scum (and you're certainly not pushing towards Naga like you are with me in your ideas). Who else does that leave?
Anyone else not on a major wagon that could have saved me because they were not on the Deku wagon. This puts a major hole into your first idea that scum didn't save me, were I scum, since the floating scum player could have saved me.
The alternative to this complicated and unnecessary scenario? I'm town that didn't bother to save myself with my own vote.
Despite all that though, when addressing the tie vote situation you simply say, "Oh I missed that. My bad," or, "True. Fair. Sorry."
Do you see how disingenuous that is? Because I do. You certainly do the mental gymnastics with painting a scenario where, as scum, I'm not saved for X and Y reasons, but when it comes to addressing the *****glaring***** reality that I could have used my vote to save myself you're rather mute on the topic at length.
Bravo. You've just skyrocketed to the top of my scum list over Ex since, with Ex, all I really had against him was just a post that seemingly looked like him coaching Chevy in reacting in thread. But you? You're going through great lengths to hedge between me, mostly, and Rubik (initially) until you settle into your idea that knowing all the roles on my wagon makes it look like I'm not town.
@ Everyone else:
At this point I'm game for either a Chevy or Caps lynch.
Strictly speaking, given this most recent post, I'm much more interested in Caps flipping. The glaring mistake/intentional lack of some logic in assessing me has me firmly in the game that Caps is scum. Chevy, for his part, still sits at a number 2 for me simply because of his flip from my initial post going after Rubik to then supporting me and how he's handled himself since then.
I, in no way, will complain if Chevy gets lynched over Caps. I will fully support either and vote to avoid any ties as needed between these two and others.
Unvote, Vote: TheCapsFan