Giri for example, as scum I've seem him do some off the wall stuff and his scumbuds didn't seem to pull the reigns in on him (I'm thinking back to like last year when he was still a relatively new player). I think a well built scum team might recognize that given the player is new, they could probably get away with a lot more than an experienced player might.
I remember being on a scum team with Giri and he would actually ask a lot what he should do.
Though he just mildly guided him and mostly let him do his own thing.
lol
I remember a previous game in which Pen basically did the exact same thing as here (barely posted D1 and flippantly shrugged it off) and ended up being town. So I’m slightly town reading him for this I guess, even if I’m not really a fan of it.
This is the same feeling I had about Pen. He's much more eager when he's mafia and chill when he's town.
Anyways, a light reads list.
Rubik - Hasn't said too much yet which is the norm for him. Null so far.
Mellow Ezlo - I tend to scum read Mez when he's town and vice versa. So no solid read on him yet, but he feels a bit scummy to me so we'll see if tradition keeps.
Mikey the Moblin - Slight town read. He doesn't feel like he does when we were scum together, granted we couldn't directly communicate. I like his pushing of Chevy's thoughts.
ExLight - Was originally slightly scum leaning him, but I'm doing less so now. His start had me feeling like his scum game and he didn't feel as genuine with his responses. I'm not sure what it was exactly that made me change. I think partially it was that he felt a bit like last game where I thought he seemed kinda scummy first off but then started town reading him.
Spiritual Mask Salesman - I think if Tristan is scum SMS is town. If Tristan is town though SMS can go either way for me. I do kinda feel a bit more of his scum play, but I could also just be reading him wrong like I often do. I'll just need more info there.
Johnny Sooshi - I usually have no clue how to read Johnny. He hasn't done anything to make me suspect him yet though. Pretty null at the moment.
Chevywolf30 - Chevy has had some thoughts that are all over the place and I didn't like his original sus of Johnny for voting Mikey when he was as well. But he seems a bit bold to be scum, and some of his posts sound genuine.
Pen - Mentioned it briefly before but slight town read because he seems chill and laid back which reminds me of town Pen. Scum Pen seems to like to get down to business early, and he loves being scum so I would have expected him to pop in sooner if he were.
Libk - Null. Kinda feel like he could be an easy mislynch here and that's why he's gaining so much traction. But I don't like the "if I'm lynched then so be it" attitude much, because yeah he did it last game as town but I don't think it's AI for him.
Kirino - Has had some solid posts so far that I've agreed with. But that's just Kirino in general so I won't have a decent read on him for a bit. Wouldn't want to lynch him though because we have some similar reads, so I feel like he might be in the same town mindset I am.
Mido - Have liked his posts a good bit so far. I don't quite remember scum Mido at this point, but he feels like he has the last few games he's been town, and once he hits a stride he's a strong player so I'm hoping to see that.
Ragnarokio - I was originally town reading Rag for her prodding of Chevy, but the more I read the more I kind of went in the opposite direction. Her posts remind me a bit of when me and her were "scum" in an NGA game together. However we weren't truly scum as our goal was to just take down one person. But we were still hiding stuff that game so it's a bit similar.
Unvote
Vote: Rag