Game Thread Mafia: The Gathering II - Gods of Kaldheim Game Thread

[The Sun Fan]

*pushes up nerd glasses*
Things can be temporarily exiled then returned to the battlefield as part of the same effect
There are a handful of cards that allow you to return a card from exile to your graveyard, but we're talking maybe four or five out of tens of thousands
Creatures can quite easily come back from the graveyard, and there are creatures called eldrazi that are capable of returning the opponent's cards from exile to their graveyard

So the short answer is no, exile probably means they aren't coming back

my experience with magic is very limited
my friend maybe had one of those cards and that's what was coloring that thought of mine?
probably not really worth talking about if none of that very small array of cards are the expected characters for the flavor of the game

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

@Rubik we might need your magic expertise here
do you understand what they’re saying

You said "aren't gods in magic killable anyway" which most are but some (like the og theros gods) have indestructible and cant be killed which actually explains why were being exiled probably
Maleficent chose to ignore context and thinks I'm a wolf for claiming to be a theros God even though flavor claiming isnt allowed

Which is lol even if they didnt show that they understand mtg

 

[ExLight]

You said "aren't gods in magic killable anyway" which most are but some (like the og theros gods) have indestructible and cant be killed which actually explains why were being exiled probably
Maleficent chose to ignore context and thinks I'm a wolf for claiming to be a theros God even though flavor claiming isnt allowed

Which is lol even if they didnt show that they understand mtg

uh and who are the gods of theros

 

[ExLight]

I don’t have reason to disagree with whatever she put out. I feel like there might be a misunderstanding

 

[Jinjo]

From what I read so far it seems like Rubik is clearing Sun Fan and on the rule it says we're not allowed to claim. ExLight's play at the end of day 1 was nai to me. ExLight actually did the same thing to me in another game when he was scum and I got mislynched the same way Minish did when I wanted ExLight to vote a scum read with me and it turned out ExLight was scum in the end.

SMS from what I remember it looked like he kept his rvs on Rubik the whole time. I often sometimes see scum who leave their vote on rvs through the end of day 1. Mikey doing a naked vote on Minish was also sus and I don't remember the reasoning on why he voted Minish. Was it because Minish was playing differently?

 

[ExLight]

**** I hit enter before I finished it

I don’t have reason to disagree with whatever she put out. I feel like there might be a misunderstanding about you softing a Theros God, but that’s about it.

If we’re using flavor to help we should probably take notes on which characters are probably too minor and which ones could be scum (considering nameclaiming is banned this prolly means characters are related to role and alignment).

ExLight actually did the same thing to me in another game when he was scum and I got mislynched the same way Minish did when I wanted ExLight to vote a scum read with me and it turned out ExLight was scum in the end.

Lol, sorry about it. Which game was that?

Mikey doing a naked vote on Minish was also sus and I don't remember the reasoning on why he voted Minish.

I think he never justified himself and neither did Sun.

 

[Jinjo]

Lol, sorry about it. Which game was that?

It was the Mafiaholics Anonymous mafia game where we had to create sock accounts. The player with the username unvote was you right? I remember when I saw the names of the anonymous players the username with the name unvote was you.

 

[ExLight]

It was the Mafiaholics Anonymous mafia game where we had to create sock accounts. The player with the username unvote was you right? I remember when I saw the names of the anonymous players the username with the name unvote was you.

ooh
yea I think that was me hahaha

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

wdym
rolecop is a typical scum role :glare:

Boi I don't know your role

 

[ExLight]

Boi I don't know your role

:glare:
only scum would have reason to check me

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

:glare:
only scum would have reason to check me

You're being close minded

 

[ExLight]

You're being close minded

I really aren’t

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Anyway, do we think Deku would make the game solvable from flavor and name claims? When we did Batmafia we sort of did make nameclaims matter I guess.

 

[ExLight]

since nameclaiming is banned it’s only natural to assume they’re AI

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

I think

I was okay with lynching someone who didnt want to lynch and minish had more votes than the other one whose name I dont remember (I want to say reki)