I think Windfall is easily the best Kakariko but since that’s not an option I’ll go with OoT. LttP was a good start, but OoT took what LttP did and expanded upon it. You can even see the progression it made from a small village to a busy(ish) town. It even continued to grow through Windwaker, where it’s not that much of a stretch to call it a small city.
TPs was so stupid though, why was it suddenly western? Before now every Kakariko seemed like a standard modern town but now it’s randomly rock ridge or whatever. There was absolutely no reason whatsoever to make it western, especially since there was already another western town in a completely different part of the map.
BotWs made a little more sense, seeing as how ever since OoT it’s been closely connected to the shiekah, a tribe of Asian ninjas, but it’s still quite a big leap from a normal town to Asian village.
I disliked LBWs for the same reason I dislike LBW as a whole. It’s the exact same as LttP’s. What’s the point of trying to explore the town you’ve already explored 100s of times? It’s just kinda boring. I’d still put it higher than TPs though.