I have not caught the softclsim. You apparently did though, so why did you vote for him?
So I want to note this because I apparently gave a misconception. I did not know Alits softclaim and actually really bad at catching them. This is going to look like BS later in this post though.
Also I can promise I'm not tunneling, I'm just applying pressure under the idea that you MIGHT be scum, and I'm only asking a few questions. I asked about Storm on D1 and i'm looking into ALIT too as you said. Not only that but wouldn't constantly going after the Masons, like others are doing, be tunneling as well?
This disturbs me. There is no reason for it. Tunneling is not alignment indicative. Town does it just as much as mafia. But this is too much of trying to make themselves look town.
I'm not feeling that any of her three scum reads (Emiya Lilac and ALIT) are actually scum which worries me a bit, surely one was snuck in there but I just don't see it.
Alit we know is town now since he's dead.
Emiya hasn't struck me as town, and Feenie may have been mafia but that doesn't mean she wasn't doing some distancing or bussing when she brought up interesting points on Emiya.
Lilac I'm pretty neutral on. There are things they do that I'm not sure are newbie mistakes or actual scummy actions.
I hate not being able to be around for eod, as seeing those posts would have definitely changed my thoughts on Feenie and I would have felt more comfortable voting her. Kinda curious about her stating that she investigated Midorikawa and sending the "results" to funnier. Could've been an opportunity to try and clear a fellow scumbud for a while, but it's hard to say either way.
Gonna look more into Feenie's reads and see if I can get anything out of those.
In case you're curious about why she investigated me-I don't actually know for sure, but my guess is just out of pure fear. She knows me, and most likely was afraid of me and wanted to know how dangerous I would be outside of just voting and analyzing. I'm pretty sure at this point on our site I'm one of the ones people want to check early on.
Yes it does!
Go to the mafia forum and click on the number of posts for this thread. (Should be 800 something) then just click on the post count of who you want to ISO.
Give this to our site too please.
Midori - Pretty good. I like.
damn sexy too Metahate and aggression is Midori's meta
Dang. This read is so amazing and accurate. A+
Not sure if there's some sort of motive there or not, since ALIT seems like he was killed for his softclaim.
Speaking of this-if this is true then it might be good to know who knew his softclaim. Curiously you have to wonder who would lie as well. We know 100% that if he was killed over his claim that it was by mafia knowing his softclaim, because we know 100% that Feenie used her rolecop on me. I have claimed to Funnier and he confirms that it is what Feenie told him. So unless I'm lying scum, then they didn't rolecop him.
Besides if I were scum, why would I go out of my way to take out my strongest teammate, especially when I'm new against veterans
..........Because they were being lynched anyways. Because they screwed up. Because by bussing your members you can win the game for your members because town will think mafia wouldn't do it.
Midori if I'm not mistaken
You are. I don't believe I ever gave any read on Lilac. Them claiming to be new makes me egh on them since it's harder to judge.
Lastly, found something interesting
when I was reading back. Voting to pressure.
Vote: @Midorikawa
That is weird.....
I also wanna know why she apparently checked mido.
I said it before. She probably did it out of fear. She probably wanted to see how much of a threat I would be.
Would Feenie be so obvious about it? Bringing attention to Midorikawa like that makes me think it was some sort of plan to make Midorikawa have suspicion thrown on her.
I know she really did check me. Idk why she kept my claim private, but maybe she hoped it would save her by making her look townier.
Good catch, Rainy. I'm down for a Lone Garu lynch (and will change my vote if it comes down to it) but want hear from Midori first.
Hi.
Also as I said before and you apparently missed that too, what scum busses their strongest player? To look good? No that would be stupid and put me at a major disadvantage if I was scum.
Smart scum. Very smart scum. Feenie was screwed the moment she claimed. She wouldn't have lived past this day phase, or at most Day 4.
While I'm still a bit suspicious of EMIYA, he seems to be soft-claiming which he does a lot as town, so I'm willing to give him benefit of the doubt for now at least. But I'm definitely going to be keeping an eye on him. Plus, there's someone else who I feel could be a decent lynch candidate for today. Midorikawa has been looking a bit suspect to me for a while. Like I said in my reads list before, I don't agree with a lot of things she's said and I find her vote on Libk extremely weird. Especially since she essentially said that she wasn't sure if he was someone that looked scummy to her, but thought he might have, so she voted for him. That's not a good reasoning. Plus the fact that from pretty much her first post in the game, she had been saying Feenie's game is off and that she wasn't making a whole lot of sense. But never voted for her, despite having reason to. And Feenie saying that she investigated Midorikawa as role cop, and messaging funnier her "results" from that could be her trying to give a scumbud a little bit of clearance for a while at least.
Vote: Midorikawa
1) I was working off memory and still am since I've been busy, hence my MIA the previous night phase. So I had the impression of some L name being suspicious to me.
2) I explained why I didn't vote Feenie. Because I don't support lynching those who can't defend themselves. If you read I said I was in support but I wasn't going to vote her when there was no confirmation on if she had internet stable enough to get on. When she did get on, I wasn't on.
3) Feenie probably thought she had a better chance at saving herself longer if she did the results privately. Funnier can confirm this since I told him all the things strange about the whole thing.
Okay my finals game finished yesterday so hey.
@Minish_Link I read the midorikawa check by feenie as spew, so I don't think midori is scum? or do you think it was an anti spew attempt?
Spew?
Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare? Can I join?
I think it's possible it was an anti spew attempt partially due to the fact that she just told funnier about it and might have been hoping that since he's a town read he would give her a slight clear for now. It would be less risky for her to do knowing that the town cop is dead.
Meh. Frankly she was completely screwed. The moment she claimed.
Ok, I think I get it now, thanks. We do also need to consider that Feenie may have simply claimed to check Mido, so she'd be able to shrug off any suspicion that might come in later. But this is getting pretty WIFOM, so I guess what I'm saying is that since we can't be sure, we really need to take Mido on her own merits, rather than trying to guess what Scum!Feenie might have done.
Thank you
And speaking of stuff. You as a fellow BMG player can confirm that mafia from our site might consider it good to make sure I'm not a super dangerous role.
Unfortunately I won't be around for eod, since I'll be going to bed here soon.
I kinda wanna trust Jamie that he views it as spew. I might just be reading too much into Midorikawa's actions because our playstyles are so different.
But if I trust that for now, that gets rid of two of my previous scum leans (since I'm giving EMIYA benefit of the doubt). Which leaves only Space as my last scum lean. I was torn between the three of them anyways, so I guess I'll go ahead and
Unvote: Midorikawa
Vote: Space
I can wait for more information to see whether or not I still feel the same about Midorikawa tomorrow.
Possibly. I don't like you either so.
So what's the case on Space?
Also on the other bmg users that aren't posting here actively: Outside of those subbing out, they also may be just forgetting to check here as it's not our home site and it may slip their minds and stuff.
