The point of lynching on Day 1 isn't necessarily due to the improbable possibility that scum will be lynched, but primarily for the sake of information and discussion. If Day 1 is nearing its end and we don't have enough evidence or suspicion to feel confident in a lynch and choose a no lynch as...
I'm against no-lynching almost as a matter of principle, so I sympathize with Cslaught in that regard, but to attempt to lynch someone so early and without any discussion or evidence is suspicious, especially when it's a middle vote like his was. I'd understand if it was just a random vote...