Which LoZ Game Should Be Remade with TP Graphics?

[Liam]

self-explanitory. which zelda game should be remade wth better and advanced graphics like those in TP???
i think Minish cap and a LttP would be WAY better in 3D, while some games like WW are never meant to be changed. they could have also done a better job wih the graphics in OoT and MM

[Josh]

I'd prefer none be remade in TP graphics, for one, they aren't the best, two, can't ever beat the originals. But if I'm forced to choose one, Link's Awakening.

[Vincent]

Adventure of Link would make a solid 3D game. I can't think of a better choice. Not only does it have a good story, the music is great, and the difficulty is a plus. They'd have to tone it down a bit though.

[Amelie]

I dont want anymore remakes. As much as I love AlttP.. I dont think Nintendo could please me with a remake. I just want a new Zelda. I guess TLOZ would make a good remake because of the story being so simple. AoL might be a very good remake though. People might actually like the game if it was remade in 3D. But I like it just enough as it is now ^^

[Ver-go-a-go-go]

I think Link's Awakening would be awesome with 3D TP graphics. But as Josh said, the games are special the way they are, so why would you even try to change them?

[bellum]

yeah, I don't really want any changed but Aol is first in line, mostly because I didn't like the graphics and I really stunk at the game but Aol for sure for me, it was a bit too hard for me and well I"m still in that one place trying to get the candle -.-.

[El Bagu]

I do not want any game re-made with TP Graphics, never liked it so much. If I had chose one I would probably go with AoL, maybe maybe the darkness of the TP graphics could fit with the AoL story and the TP graphics actually has some bright moments (and we do not have to experience the twilight :clap:). Anyway I would not mind to play a 3D version of AoL, would be great! Another candidate could be OoA, it is interesting and would do great as a 3D game.

[Petman1325]

I want to see Ocarina of Time be redone, but in TP's graphics quality, not actual models. That wouldn't look right. I mean, the lighting engine, textures, and AI would have to be better (Such as, OoT enemies only attack you if they see or hear you, or you hit them, but TP enemies go with if they see, hear, attack, or the death of a comrade).

[Kybyrian]

To me it would take away the feeling of the game and it would seem like a whole different game only with the same story, adventure, items, and such. I would prefer that not any of them be made with graphics such as the graphics that they used for Twilight Princess.

[Dark_Kokiri]

Honestly, I like how every game seems to have their own set of graphics. It identifies them as their own game and more so what the feeling of the game is.

It's like in Wind Waker, they chose to go with cell shading. Why? It was not only made for a younger audience, but it gave you an idea, or a feeling, on what kind of game it is. Now, I love Wind Waker, I love the cell shading graphics and I love the game. It's my second favorite, OoT being the first. I think that the Wind Waker graphics not only are kid-froendly, but they kinda make you look at the Zelda games from a different angle. Up until that point, all the graphics were more serious and realistic. Wind Waker turned that around, and that's why it was a huge sucess, I believe.

Twilight Princess was revolunitary because they are the most realistic graphics to date in the Zelda history. It identifies it as a game to be taken more seriously than Wind Waker.


I don't know how much of that made sense.....I'm not good at explaining things. XD But basically I'm saying that each game's graphics gives each Link their own identity, so I don't think taht graphics should be mixed because of this reason.

[Midna666]

I would really not want any of the Zelda games to be remade with TP's graphics,I like the games the way they are.
But if I had to pick one I would pick ALTTP.

[Kitsu]

I wouldn't really want any of them remade. Remaking Twilight Princess with its own graphics seems useless....
But if any were to be remade I would say Adventure of Link or Majora's Mask. Even though the latter is already relatively realistic, I would like to see it remade with the TP graphics to enhance the dark, and impending feeling of it.

[Uroboros]

None of them. Wii's graphics can be pushed so much farther than what Twilight Princess showed us. I'd so much rather see a new game with a new engine.

[Alter]

I thing ALttP/LA. LA was one of my favs, and I think it could have a lot more detail in it if it was 3D. Same with ALttP, but that wasn't one of my favorites...

Oh, and BTW, GANNON-BANNED!!! It's "Adventure of Link", not "Adventures of Link", per rule #2.>:(

Sorry 'bout the disruption there, sheriff.

[Hanyou]

I like the idea of a remake. Any good game that's old enough deserved an update, and I'm not suggesting that the update replace the original, just that it could be a decent way to revisit the world (Pokemon Leaf Green is a great example of a remake, while Starfox 64 is an example of an overhaul. Both work well). TP's graphics, however, consisted of unimaginative shades of brown and gray, and hardly looked like anything I'd want to be revisiting. I certainly think graphical enhancements are fine for some of the games (for example, if Link's Awakening were ever remade in 3D, TWW's graphics would be perfect).

TP's graphics just aren't up to snuff for any purpose within the Zelda universe. When I play a Zelda game, I want to feel like I'm on an adventure, like I'm discovering an ancient but vibrant world. OoT's graphics fulfill that purpose. So do TWW's. TP's certainly don't.

[Dabombster]

None of them. A remake is not what Zelda needs, it needs a new game. I don't know about all of you guys, but I really would not want to play a game I've beaten, instead of having a new game to play and conquer. I think that if Nintendo actually took the time to do this, it would be a waste of their time. They wouldn't even profit too much from it. The only game I can see them gaining something from would be remaking OoT with TP graphics. It doesn't need it, but OoT is so overrated and 'loved' that people would buy it with the newer, better graphics anyway.

So no, I would not like to see a Zelda game remade. Ever.

[Shnappy]

I'm not entirely sure about games being remade with TP "Graphics"
What I would really want to see would be games like OoT and MM (not sure about TWW) remade with wii CONTROLS.
It's just the epicness of TP with "Real sword swinging action (lol) with the wii remote" that would make OoT and MM so cool on the wii.

[chrisbg99]

Why would anyone want the 2D games "re-done" in 3D? It just wouldn't be the same as things that work in a 2D don't work in 3D nearly as well, unless you are just talking 2.5D but I don't think you are.

[Liam]

yeah i made a mistake. TP could not be remade with its own quality graphics. so just ignore that option. oh, y the way, i think you misunderstood me when i said REMADE i meant to just make the same game with TP quality, not have it totally overdone and trying to beat the first version.
oh the ones i would choose would be aLttP and OoT.

[Link 2 the past]

I don't think they should waste time with re-makes of any of the games. They are fine the way they are.

[Liam]

i know every game has its unique graphics, but if you HAD to choose one to make it better, which would it be?

[MOS3]

I love OoT, but from what I've read it is somewhat familiar to TP...so I'd say.... Majora's Mask....such an awesome game.....weould be great to see taht game with current graphics :)

[MajoraKing12]

I have to say Majora's Mask because it would be so awesome to see Firece Deity in Twilight Princess graphics! And when the moon comes down and alot of other stuff in TP graphics.:)

[Majora Mistress]

I want them all to be remade in 64 bit....Just Kidding. This was a really hard question- I love how the graphics are unique to each game and help set the themes of the games. I really wouldn't have them any other way. So I chose AoL because it is my least favorite- so maybe a graphic update (Instead of side scrolling. D8) would make it better?

[Durion]

My answer is OoT, That game was brilliant and with better graphics it would make Link look slightly better since I have always thought adult Link had a really funny looking nose.

One question though, Why have you given us the choice to choose to get Twilight Princess remade in TP's Graphics.

[Myungster]

I'm glad you put ALttP and LA together.

Because those 2 have my vote.
Reason being is they are my favorite Zelda games..

The catch is I prefer OoT/MM graphics better than TP.

That's just me.

[Myungster]

I'd also like to see Link's Adventure in TP graphics...


That would be cool, too.

[Liam]

One question though, Why have you given us the choice to choose to get Twilight Princess remade in TP's Graphics.


yeah i made a mistake. TP could not be remade with its own quality graphics. so just ignore that option. oh, y the way, i think you misunderstood me when i said REMADE i meant to just make the same game with TP quality, not have it totally overdone and trying to beat the first version.
oh the ones i would choose would be aLttP and OoT.

maybe you should read the other posts before you go asking questions like that.

[Chris]

I agree with Josh, no Zelda game should be made with advanced graphics, especially OoT. Those graphics ruin the cartoon aspect of the game and replace it with an atmosphere that is too serious, drawing away the fun.

If I had to chose one, it would be MM because I think that all those forms of Link would be cool to see in those graphics, but that is all.

[vatti]

I think MC would be the best to be remade with TP graphics, cause I would like to see what Ezlo would look like. That isn't the only reason but it's one of them.

[athenian200]

Ocarina of Time. Why?

Well, because, quite frankly... I wish they had done that instead of releasing TP. All the enhancements made in TP except for Wolf Link could have easily been incorporated into OoT somewhere along with the new graphics. In fact, that's one reason I'd want to see this. I want them to put some horseback fighting sequences into OoT along with the graphical overhaul. :)

Besides... OoT needs and deserves it. The tearing polygons and low framerates mar the game badly on modern television sets. Plus, it's the only way we'll ever see Shiek again outside of SSBB.

[majoraskullkid]

I would choose LttP because it is really a good game and it has an awesome story. So, I think that with 3D grraphics it would be a plus and it would become my favorite Zelda game.

[Master Kokiri 9]

If any, it should be OoT and MM. They just seem like the only ones that could be done well. They always struck me as the type of games to have those kinds of graphics if they were a current gen game. But other than that, none at all.

[TheSerpent]

I think Majora's Mask should be remade for the wii with better graphics, and maybe an extended storyline/gameplay. It was released near the end of the N64's time, so it isn't getting the credit it deserves.

[Mikau94]

I loved Ocarina of Time, but I've beat it so many times, It would be weird to see it change. I also liked Majora's Mask, it didn't get enough credit and a remake would be great.

[cracky37]

lol i think Oot would make a good remake with better graphics but i might grow to miss the old graphics as they are a nice memory